Low-cost antenna shootout 70cm

From wikipost
Jump to navigationJump to search

These days, many low-cost antennas for the 70cm ISM band can be obtained from online sellers though eBay and Amazon. I was curious to see how well they performed in a variety of environments. I was also interested to see how well my own design, the 'Captcha' PCB dipole, would stack up against these commercially available antennas.

Here, we put several models to the test.

The contestants are:

Name Radiation Pattern Gain (specified) Price
centre-loaded quarter wave vertical
Omnidirectional 3dBi AU$7.67
J-Pole on a PCB
Omnidirectional ? AU$1.52
short helical quarter wave
Omnidirectional 2-3dBi AU$1.20
sleeve dipole
Omnidirectional 6dBi AU$3.59
captcha pcb dipole
Omnidirectional ? US$9.01
quarter wave vertical 'monopole' 150mm wire antenna
Omnidirectional ?dBi (free)
short helical with PL259 connector
Omnidirectional 2.5dBi AU$14.09

How the range was determined

I tested these antennas on low power at 2.5uW (-26dBm). For range testing I wrote two sketches; one for a stationary 'base' unit, and one for the mobile unit that I took with me whilst walking away. The mobile unit is equipped with a LED and a piezo buzzer and sends out a packet every 2 seconds. When the base unit receives a packet, it re-sends it at full power (100mW, 20dBm) back to the mobile unit. When the mobile unit receives the re-sent ack packet a short beep is sent to a piezo transducer. That tells me that the base station can still receive the packets. I know that I've reached the range limit when I stop hearing confirmation beeps. For this test I did not rely on GPS as the distances are relatively short and GPS would probably introduce a significant measurement error of several metres. Instead, I just walked it out and counted my steps. This test is all about the relative range between the various antennas, NOT the real range when using radios at maximum power.

The Candidates


The Base Station and terrain

I tested in a small park surrounded by trees and residential buildings, a level field, no immediate buildings nearby, dry soil ground.

The distances shown below were obtained by attenuating the signal down to -26dBm using a 30dB SMA attenuator. This was done purely to limit the range to well within the size of a small park where I did the testing.

The Mobile Unit with a 30dB attenuator

The results:

Name Distance Rank
centre-loaded quarter wave vertical 50m 4
J-Pole on a PCB 21m 6
short helical quarter wave 58m 2
sleeve dipole 55m 3
captcha pcb dipole 75m 1
quarter wave vertical 16cm wire antenna 31m 5
short helical with PL259 connector N/A N/A