Surface Mount FETs compared

From wikipost
Revision as of 19:09, 13 December 2019 by Admin (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigationJump to search

One particular electronics component that I often found difficult to pick for my projects is the venerable MOSFET. The FET (Field Effect Transistor) is part of the Transistor family of semiconductors. There are many types of transistors, but they basically fall in one of these three broad categories:

  • Current-driven: BJT (Bipolar Junction Transistor)
  • Voltage-driven: FET (JFET and MOSFET)
  • Other (e.g. phototransistors)


In this overview I focus mostly on Enhancement-mode MOSFETs and present a selection guide with examples.


BJTs and FETs can be used for either switching or amplification, but generally one type performs better than the other.

Consider:

  • BJTs require a constant current flow through the base in order for the transistor to open. This base-driven current flow can easily exceed the current rating of microcontroller ports and additional drivers (BJTs or FETs) are often required to enable higher drive currents. BJTs however outperform FETs in terms of amplification factor. Although BJTs can be used for switching purposes, they are not the most obvious choice when we need to save overall power consumption.
  • FETs are voltage driven and can usually be connected directly to microcontroller ports. There is the factor of inrush-current if a FET has a high capacitance, but a simple series current-limiting resistor is sufficient to deal with that. FETs may also need to be selected to be compatible with the logic-level (TTL) voltages and may therefore also require additional drivers to enable higher (or lower) drive voltages. They are however a better choice than BJTs when it comes to low-power switching.


Lastly, before we get to our overview, there is one more distinction I want to address: JFET vs MOSFET. The JFET (Junction-FET) has certain benefits over the MOSFET. JFETs have a simpler production process and are therefore usually cheaper. JFETs also have higher gate input capacitance which makes them more robust to ESD (Electro-Static Discharge) compared to MOSFETs. However, since MOSFETs are the FET of choice for big players like Intel their prices have come down and characteristics have improved. It seems that, like BJTs, JFETs are slowly but steadily giving way to MOSFETs for many applications except where their niche is unchallenged.


(This page is a work in progress)



Vgsth

The threshold value when the FET begins conducting. A bigger voltage difference between Gate and Source than this value will open the FET more. This value is usually shown in the Id-vs-Vgs 'Transfer Characteristics' graph. At the point where the curve (up) becomes a near-linear line the FET is fully open. We generally seek the lowest voltage where the FET is about to become linear.


Vds

The maximum voltage the FET can safely handle between the Drain and Source.


Id

The maximum continuous current we can run through the Drain of the FET. This value is dependent on the maximum Drain-Source voltage. FETs running at a higher voltage need to lower their maximum current. The value for this characteristic is usually shown in the Id-vs-Vds(V) graph, aka the 'Safe operating area' graph.


RdsOn

The resistance between Drain and Source when the FET is fully open. The value for this characteristic is usually shown in the Rdson-vs-Id(mA) graph.




N-Channel, Enhancement-mode MOSFETs

Device Vgsth Vds Id RdsOn Comments
2N2002
BSS138
#3
#4




RdsOn - the higher the difference between Gate and Source the lower the On-Resistance between Drain and Source (Rdson). Therefore, if the Vgsth has a low value it is easier to get a better (lower) on-resistance (which is probably what you want).

If you can't get a big enough difference between Gate and Source, then the next candidate to lower the Rdson resistance is to push less current through it.

Typically, if we're using N-Channel FETs driven directly from a microcontroller, the drive voltage is probably going to be 1.8V, 3.3V or 5.0V. It is therefore best to select FETs that have a Vgsth of no more than the Vcc that we're powering the microcontroller with.




P-Channel, Enhancement-mode MOSFETs

Device Vgsth Vds Id RdsOn Comments Datasheet
BSH203 -1.1V -30V -40mA @ 10Vds, -80mA @ 5Vds, -105mA @ 3.3Vds 0.8R @ -4.5Vgs, 0.9R @ -2.5Vgs File:BSH203.pdf
NDS352AP -2.5V @ -10Vds -30V -50mA @ 10Vds, -100mA @ 5Vds, -105mA @ 3.3Vds 0.95R @ -4.5Vgs, 1.4R @ -3.3Vgs
BSS84 -1.9V @ -10Vds -50V -25mA @ -10Vds, -50mA @ 5Vds, -70mA @ 3.3Vds 10R @ -4.5Vgs, 17R @ -3.3Vgs
#4